Monday, March 5

Um... Are These the Same Book?

So for the past few days I've been reading Crossed at home and listening to Delirium in the car. And... I've come to the conclusion that they are more or less the same book. Check out my nifty chart for comparison's sake.

(Click the image to make it bigger)

I really do not mean this as a criticism of either book! I'm enjoying them both quite a lot (Ok, maybe enjoying Crossed a titch more!), but I just keep getting confused because they are so darn similar.

What do you think, book lovers? Did I miss any other similarities? Can you think of another book pairing where it was easy to confuse the two stories?

9 comments:

  1. Ha! That is very close isn't it?? Wow. Great chart, I like seeing it all mapped out. I couldn't finish Crossed and I find myself liking Oliver's series a bit more at this point but the similarities are so very there!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Holy cow those are a heck of a lot of similarities! I'm a huge lover of Delirium and am reading Pandemonium now, but still need to read the Matched trilogy. I'll definitely be looking for the comparisons when I start it! Loved your chart too!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lol! I guess that's one of the dangers of reading more than one book at a time (though I do it all the time). I haven't read either of these series yet, but I remember thinking that they sounded similar in nature when they first came out.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I didn't realize the similarities - but there are quite a lot of them, aren't there?! Maybe it's just that there are special requirements for dystopian societies in a writing handbook somewhere.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Since I looooved Matched, sounds like I need to add Delirium to my TBR. Thanks for the heads up.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think they probably have a lot of similarities with other dystopian novels, as well. I didn't really notice, although I read those books back to back last year, but Lena and Cassia are so different in my mind that it never occurred to me....

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think since I read these two months apart from each other I didn't really notice the similarities... but wow. They do have a lot of the same themes. However, I think a lot of dystopian books have some of these themes, so it could slightly be coincidental. Love the chart though :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yup, I remember thinking these were really similar too. And really, the comparisons don't stop there. Many, many dystopians coming out these days seem to follow the same basic formula.

    ReplyDelete

Reading your comments is one of my favorite parts of Book Love! Thanks for sharing your thoughts and suggestions.

Related Posts with Thumbnails